Your option is limited to having an amplifier with input stage suitable for instrument levels and impedances, and enough amplification for driving the chip input with suitable amplitude. It does not look much different than your mic or line input buffer. There are plenty of guitar amp examples you can use, even service manuals of commercial guitar amps.
For non-hifi purposes any op-amp will do. The NE5532 is used in many professional circuits as it is a very good for audio. So it's better but then again you are using lo-fi components such as ISD1820, it will not make much difference if you use an op-amp far better than what you need.
The op-amp stages you have drawn will not work, as the circuits expect a bipolar supply. Either change the circuit to work with single supply or change the power supply to proviede bipolar voltages.