4

There is no information I can find (charts/specifications) that gives the ampacity for single core silver wire. But I know this can be calculated, I've found this property list for silver from a [metals supplier][1]

Thermal Conductivity: 428 W/m * K at 20 oC 356 W/m * K at 450 oC

Electrical Properties:

Electrical Conductivity: 108.4% IACS for extremely pure silver

Electrical Resistivity: 14.7 nΩ * m at 0 oC

Temperature Coefficient: from 0 to 100 oC, 0.0041 per K

Cold working of silver considerably increases resistivity: 5% for 90% reduction.

Any ideas why this information is not available anywhere? I'd love to know how this is calculated and what it would be for 14 gauge (2.5mm wire).

Many thanks!

user1009762
  • 43
  • 1
  • 5
  • 12
    I think it's the reciprocal of the ampishness. – Ian Bland Jan 19 '18 at 14:15
  • 9
    If you can afford silver wire, you can afford to hire a Nobel-prize holding scientist to advise you on ampacity. – user57037 Jan 19 '18 at 15:31
  • 7
    Where does one even get silver wire in such a high gauge, and what is it for? I'd assume the rarity is the reason you don't see it on commonly available charts. – JPhi1618 Jan 19 '18 at 16:21
  • 5
    Anti-dracula machine??! –  Jan 19 '18 at 16:41
  • 3
    Silver is very similar to copper. Very slightly more conductive (not enough to really matter), very slightly denser (not enough to really matter). It's less malleable, however, and more prone to cracking and fatigue failures... given that it's about 5-6 times the cost of copper you'd be hard pressed to come up with a good reason to use it as a wire (which is why nobody does - not counting "audiophiles" who treat science rather more like witchcraft). – J... Jan 19 '18 at 17:00
  • 2
    @GregoryKornblum Didn't you know? Most SWAT teams across the world now employ vampires. The OP is clearly looking to build a bomb that they can't defuse. – Nic Jan 19 '18 at 18:31
  • 4
    I always thought silver was used against werewolves... – Finbarr Jan 19 '18 at 18:42
  • 1
    Either way, is it going to be an electric chair? –  Jan 19 '18 at 20:57
  • 1
    Isn't aluminium more conductive per unit mass than silver or copper? – Nick T Jan 19 '18 at 20:57
  • *[Ampacity](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ampacity)* (Wikipedia) = *current limit*, *current rating*, or *maximum current* (continuous, average (RMS)). – Peter Mortensen Jan 19 '18 at 22:25
  • 1
    @mkeith, silver wire isn't that expensive. At a ballpark estimate, 14-gauge wire would cost around $4 per foot -- more than copper, but far less than a Nobel-prize physicist. – Mark Jan 19 '18 at 22:55
  • 1
    What is the going rate for a Nobel-prize physicist? – user57037 Jan 19 '18 at 23:02
  • 3
    Depends if you're paying in paper dollars or silver wire. – Ian Bland Jan 19 '18 at 23:39
  • 1
    I will happily trade anyone any amount of copper wire for any amount of silver wire they may care to unload. Length for length, and circular mil for circular mil. Also, happy to trade 10 pre-1982 (copper) pennies for each pre-63 (silver) US dime you are looking to get rid of. – user57037 Jan 20 '18 at 03:38
  • 14 gauge copper wire can handle 15 amps even if you get an 8 % boost that is 16amp. Not worth it. You can buy 12 gauge copper way cheaper to handle 20A. – cybernard Jan 20 '18 at 04:23

7 Answers7

14

In general the current rating of a wire is limited by the wire's ability to dissipate heat to its surroundings without getting too hot. That in turn depends on the maximum safe wire temperature and the thermal resistance to ambient. Unfortunately figuring out exactly what the thermal resistance to ambient is for a given installation method is nontrivial.

Unfortunately standards don't normally say how they came up with the tabulated figures but one can assume they were determined from experimental data.

We can come up with a figure for a silver wire by assuming that the acceptable heat dissipation for a silver wire of a given size is the same as that for a copper wire of the same size. We divide the resistivity of silver by that of copper and then take the square root (remember \$P=I^2R\$).

Using numbers from this table tells us that a silver wire should have about 1.03 times the current carrying capacity of a copper wire of the same size installed under the same conditions.

This is small enough that other factors (exact installation method, material purity, how the material was worked into a wire etc) are likely to outweigh the difference between silver and copper.

psmears
  • 678
  • 4
  • 6
Peter Green
  • 21,158
  • 1
  • 38
  • 76
6

Other than material and gauge, ampacity is limited by insulation temperature rating, maximum ambient temperature, bundling (how many other wires, and how much current are they carrying) and by altitude and the anticipated installation conditions. A PTFE-insulated wire that is allowed to run at 180°C will carry a lot more current safely than one that is only allowed to run at 105°C, especially if the ambient temperature is high (the ratio increases as the maximum ambient temperature increases and becomes infinite at the ambient equal to the lower rated wire).

So basically just use tables for copper of equivalent insulation under the equivalent conditions and you'll be "about right" and slightly on the safe side. Silver wire may not be approved for residential electrical wiring, aircraft use, or other specific applications, however, so keep whatever standards you may have to meet in mind.

If it's speaker wire there are no standards as far as I'm aware, nor do you typically have ampacity issues. We used AWG8 silver-plated copper conductors deep inside very expensive plastic molds (think 2l pop bottles- but at the preform stage, not the blow molding). The wire was MIL-spec not UL.


Bare wire is another thing altogether. The "fusing current" for silver is about 75% of that of copper of equivalent diameter, based on the ratio of fusing constants.

Spehro Pefhany
  • 376,485
  • 21
  • 320
  • 842
4

You won't find an answer easily because it depends on many other factors as well. The ones listed for copper are usually standards for use in construction.

The current carrying capability of a wire depends on, amongst other things:

  1. The operating conditions of the wire
  2. The allowed maximum voltage drop across the wire for a given current
  3. The maximum temperature the wire is allowed to reach because of either safety concerns (it might cause damage or risk starting a fire if it gets too hot) or the temperature the insulation can handle without melting.

There may be additional factors, such as the environment of the cable. For example, if the cable is to be used in a large harness with many others, it will be able to carry less current as it will have a harder time getting rid of heat because of the other cables (that might also be getting warm). Hence, the current that cable may carry could be significantly lower than what it can carry when suspended in the air on its own.

Long story short: You can't find any information because it depends, and in addition, I have never really heard of anyone using solid silver as conductor.

Joren Vaes
  • 12,376
  • 33
  • 64
  • You will find a lot of audiophools that use silver cables everywhere – PlasmaHH Jan 19 '18 at 14:26
  • 1
    @PlasmaHH just make sure that the silver is oxygen free and the grain structure is aligned propperly – Joren Vaes Jan 19 '18 at 14:32
  • 2
    Values for pure silver conductors will be nearly the same as pure copper conductors since the thermal and electrical conductivity of silver and copper are within 10% of each other. Since copper ampacity tables exist for a variety of installation conditions and insulation material, they can also be used for silver. – davidmneedham Jan 19 '18 at 14:33
  • 3
    @JorenVaes: I would only use it with a lessloss blackbody field conditioner. – PlasmaHH Jan 19 '18 at 14:55
3

Maximum current for a wire is primarily limited by overheating and power loss concerns. Both of these are proportional to the resistance of the wire. Heating is further affected by insulation, airflow, and so on around the wire.

For a simple estimation, you can use any table for copper wire you like, and multiply the ampacity by \$\sqrt{1.084}\$ since silver (by your data) has 108.4% the conductivity of copper, and power loss is proportional to the square of current (\$P=I^2R\$). This is assuming silver wire of identical geometry, insulation, and environment.

Phil Frost
  • 56,804
  • 17
  • 141
  • 262
1

audiophools...yeah as in their silver cables are silver plated copper. Which is much sillier than gold plated cable contacts.

Silver tarnishes. While tarnish protects from further corrosion similar to oxides on aluminum...silver tarnish is not nearly as conductive as untarnished silver.

Gold at least has the virtue of yielding a zero corrosion contact surface even with careless handling over decades (unless frequently enough plugged and unplugged that gold wears off). Though somewhat pointless if interior mating of female connectors is not also gold and is corroded (which many audiophools overlook).

Of course if you properly handle cheap chrome or other common connectors they won't have significant corrosion deposits either. I.E. Avoid touching with finger oils and other corrosives and polish off finger oils at least once a year/decade (depending on metal and corrosive).

user175346
  • 11
  • 1
  • This does not answer the OPs question, which is mostly about the chemical properties of silver. Silver is used a great deal by the radar industry. Doppler radar front end boards work at GHZ frequencies. The silver is usually gold plated to avoid corrosion. –  Jan 20 '18 at 06:02
1

It seems to be that while silver is a better heat and electrical conductor, it's lower fusing constant (1900 vs 2530 for copper) make it act more like a fuse and less like a conductor. Curiously, solder is 325.5. That's the number of Amps to fuse a 1cm diameter wire in still air

So, since it is 8.1% more conductive and fuses at 24.1% less current then the answer is really that while is more efficient at carrying current, it can actually carry less for a given thickness. I imagine a superconductor that heats itself up in use, above the magic temperature... poof! Pure silver does not oxidize (like gold) and become more resistive, but once alloyed with copper or nickel (and others) it does oxidize, get higher resistance, and depending on the alloy, the change can be rapid.

For Copper you will find it changes its resistance once annealed.

  • How it is calculated from a safety and standards viewpoint?
    https://www.copper.org/consumers/copperhome/HomePlan/safety/Lvng_cde_rdcs_rsks.html.
  • How I would adopt use of silver in place of copper? Allow 1.3315 times the diameter that you would use if it were copper. That's the actual value and meaning of fusing constant 2530/1900.
  • Direct answer the ampacity of pure silver 14 gauge wire is (1900/2530)*the ampacity of 14 gauge copper wire.
  • 0.750 * coppers' ampacity.
0

Lots of good answers. Most of which point toward the answer having no practical use outside an academic test. Pure silver is expensive and much softer than common copper wiring. Without reference I believe it introduces the same bi-metal issues as mixing aluminum and copper wiring. Thus silver is undesirable from engineering and theft standpoints.

Some of those engineering points become even more complex as you attempt to alleviate them. As was mentioned both alloying and working silver cause phase and density changes in silver plus the other included metals.

In reality standard amperage carrying capacity of copper and other wire in industry is based on a number assumptions: standard alloy, insulating materail, ambient temperature and humidity, minimum air space and circulation, safety margins. The most common of these standards are building codes for interior wiring where wire temperatures must not melt the insulation nor ignite paper or wood. I cannot remember if the US safety margin was 30% or 50% -- but I do remember that it was quite generous to allow for startup surge currents of electric motors and such.

A slightly different capacity standard is sometimes used in enclosed electronics. There ignition temperatures of paper/wood is replaced by softening/melting temperatures of wire itself...although the melting point of wire insulating material usually remains the governing factor except inside vacuum tubes.

So for that all important academic test or EXOTIC electronics application...I would say the question is missing a plethora of qualifying environmental criteria (ambient operating environment: temperature range and anything connected to cooling: such as surrounding gas/liquid composition and flow volume, other thermal sources, thicknesses of surrounding thermal conducting media {like part of heat sink}, etc etc)

Ultimately only a very few remote exotic environments (mostly space or deep sea) or microchips would justify even momentary consideration of silver as an alternative to just using a more over-engineered version of the standard copper circuits. Last I heard even micro-chips were considering copper more and more for chip to substrate connections as a replacement for gold assuming that corrosion issues could be overcome. And at those fine diameters I don't think silver has much advantage over copper as the protective tarnish becomes relatively thick to the application and plays hell with resistance calculations.

  • A better answer would not have so much 'fluff' added. Your drifting into territory that does not directly answer the OPs question. I know this is mostly a math question, but silver is used extensively by the radar industry for Doppler radar front-end boards, due to the GHZ frequencies on the board, usually made of Teflon. –  Jan 20 '18 at 05:57