Since you haven't listed the pH sensor your trying to interface to, I'll comment on what is involved:
1) The input impedance of the amplifier needs to be higher than the source impedance of the pH sensor. Another way of saying this is the output current of the pH sensor needs to be higher than the input current of the amplifier. Find the pH probe datasheet and look for an impedance or current number, then size your amplifier impedance or current.
2) Leakage currents are a problem. When resistances are similar, every material becomes a conductor. Teflon, Kapton and a few other materials have high resistances. Usually a guard trace or ring is used so even if the material (like FR4 which would leak a large portion of the current from the trace) the voltage is the same as the input so there is minimal leakage current. You can build your own guard ring by matching the voltage of the input with a buffer amplifier from the output. Kind of like this example
The best one is going to have the highest impedance, it will be easier to interface to something like the INA116 which already has guard ring buffers built into the amplifier. There are a few others that do this also.